Recently, a group of 4 of us decided to check out the fish house to see what all of the hype was about.
One of us ordered a double chop, one fish/chips, one shrimp/mashed potatoes, one a steak. Steak: well-done as ordered.
double-chop: while large, was flavorless
Shrimp: also flavorless
Fish/chips: eh....not bad, not good.
We all agreed that the new place seemed afraid to season anything. The atmosphere was loud and the decor odd for where it's located.
Service was okay. It was so loud, you had to yell to speak with the waitress who either couldn't hear well enough or was pre-occupied as she had to be asked time and again for the same thing.
Another note that folks should know: Beer/wine only. Not a full bar.
Like many that occupied this space before....I'm guessing the fish house is just passing through. Unless of course they figure out what the LOCALS really want in a new restaurant. However, the LOCALS don't seem to be the priority. Tourists come and go with their $$$.........to make it here, you need to take care of your own.
If you own or manage Stillwater Fish House, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.