My wife and I went there to celebrate Mother's Day and our 30th Anniversary. Friends had taken us there as a thank-you previously. We were impressed and decided to go back. We were not disappointed! I had made the reservation online, noting the special occasion. The owner greeted us and wished us a Happy Anniversary; my wife didn't know I had mentioned that.
Our server, Ellie, was friendly and efficient. Midway through dinner she took our picture; we thought it was for their album. We were pleasantly surprised a few minutes later when she presented us with the photo in a little frame with anniversary greetings.
Try the crab cake appetizer-it's big enough for two. Lots of succulent crab meat, very little filler and lightly pan fried.
My wife had the prime rib eye steak. It was cooked to perfection (medium). At 14 ounces it was too much for one person, but she enjoyed the remainder at home the next day.
The sushi grade scallops are a real treat. These are pan seared and they are moist, tender and very, tasty.
As a topper to our evening, we were treated to a piece of excellent cheesecake, compliments of the house to commemorate our anniversary.
The view of the lake is spectacular, so ask for a table where you can see the view.
If you own or manage Baxter's Lakeside Grille, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.