We ate at McElroys several years ago and liked the food, so after a 9 hour drive I was ready for peel and eat shrimp which I of course expected to be fresh. However the shrimp had a strange texture and flavor. After trying several of the 25 small shrimps I asked the waitress if they were fresh. I didn't get a warm fuzzy answer but she took them back. Asked if I wanted anything else and I declined as my husband had his shrimp which were not peel and eat. Waitress said no charge for my meal and dessert free. Bread pudding was excellent but my husband's cheesecake was tasteless. Not the waitress' fault at all and she handled situation well. Not sure I'd give this another try though.
If you own or manage McElroys Seafood, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.