This old house is an institution in itself and offers a great menu served by excellent staff. They have added window seating around the exterior so there's more room but definitely book in advance. I had snapper (two filets) that came with a thin pasta covered with crawfish etouffe and it was really good. Prices are okay for the beach so don't be worried.
If you own or manage Mary Mahoney's Old French House, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.