My wife and I were visiting Stillwater for the day and stopped here for a late lunch/early dinner. The restaurant was quite full and we were told it would be about a 10 minute wait as we requested to sit outside. We were promptly called in exactly 10 minutes and sat at a table outside. Our server was very prompt and took good care of us with refilling drinks etc. The food arrived so quickly that we honestly thought that the server was delivering it to the wrong table. It came that quick! The food tasted good and the portions were good. My wife had The jerk pork tacos and I had the ribs. The tacos were good and as expected. The ribs tasted good with jerk barbecue sauce however they were just a bit on the tough side. I consider myself a rib expert and realize they are tough to get just right. They tasted great and were most certainly edible. The million dollar question – would I come here again? The answer is yes. The only negative mark I would give the place is that the outdoor seating is right next to the road and a little bit noisy.
If you own or manage Smalley's Caribbean Barbeque, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.