We attended Carmelo's on a Saturday evening expecting something unique, based on the reviews here. What we found was friendly service, overpriced mediocre wines and average cooking. The calamari was under cooked and the crab stuffed mushrooms were cool. My signature dish, Chicken Carmelo, was good with a nice sauce but I expected more crispiness in the crust and more crab topping from the signature dish. My wife had the seafood cannelloni and was generally disappointed expecting more a seafood taste. It was overpowered by the sauce. I am planning on another trip back just to make sure this wasn't just a bad kitchen night.
If you own or manage Carmelo's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.