I would have gone with a 5, but for a couple tiny flaws.
We got a great booth right away, and ordered our wine with no problem. Service was excellent, attentive and personable without being intrusive. I ordered the Barramundi, since this is one of the few places I can get it. My partner ordered the Walleye, since this is Minnesota! We had oysters, and King Crab legs as appetizers. Although I ordered the Bluepoint oysters, what arrived weren't Bluepoints, and the delivery lady couldn't be persuaded they weren't. They were tasty, but seemed to be PEIs of some sort. I'm not an aficionado, but I've had a few of each over the years.
I've also had a few waiters in the past few decades, but I've never experienced one that liked to gently slap my shoulder quite so often. One or two wasn't so bad, but it was a little irritating after awhile. I'm just glad it wasn't the shoulder I'd had surgery on recently.
The food was exceptional, as it always is. The portions make it a value for the price. The ambiance is classy without being stuffy. The location is impeccable. I can only think of a few seafood restaurants I've been to which would be better, but none of them are within 800 miles of this place.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.