I've eaten here twice, once on my own at the bar, once with friends. Both experiences were great, huge improvement over the previous disappointing restaurant in this location.
Staff was friendly and attentive, to us it seemed as if at least some effort had been made in training them. Beer list is decent, but they are also touting their Bourbon list. Flight of Bulleit? was pretty good but I'm not really a bourbon fan, others will have their own opinions. :) Burgers were very good, appetizers as well, all our meals were good. Nothing was lacking on either occasion. Glad to see them here, will be back quite often.
When they started I think they were open till 1am every night, but their current website doesn't reflect that. May have been too slow during the week for that to continue, but they are at least open till midnight Friday/Saturdays.
If you own or manage Tavern 4 & 5, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.