This was our third time to Martha's mostly because there aren;t tons of restaurants in Sutton's Bay. The first time we had dinner there it was average, our server was terrible. The second time breakfast was ok but overpriced but at least the server was better. The third time the food was poor and we had the terrible sever again. My husband had some special where dessert was included. His steak was overcooked and dry. My chicken dish was very dry and was supposed to be stuffed with cheese I tasted none. Then dessert came (which the server didn't tell us what it was) she just threw on the table, it had nuts in it, my husband is allergic to them! I love Suttons
Bay but Martha's is off my list.
If you own or manage Martha's Leelanau Table, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.