We have been coming to Mackinaw City to celebrate our anniversary for many years. One of our highlights of the entire area is the night we have dinner at Darrow's. Yes, there is a line out the door - but trust me, it is well worth the wait. The line actually goes rather quickly, but even if it takes a minute, you won't be sorry!
My husband had the liver and onions (yuck)...LOL...but it was cooked perfectly. Liver is very easy to over-cook, but it was thick and tasty and tender. The sign on the wall says they only serve home-made mashed potatoes, and you can actually tell that. I ordered the crab-stuffed whitefish and was totally surprised at the flavor, the delicious, tender, melt in your mouth......
The pies are to die for, as everyone says. But they make as many as they can and they still run out at the end of the day quite often. We have been known to order our pie before we eat (and then sometimes take one home to eat later).
The servers are very busy, but friendly and give great service. Don't miss your chance for an awesome dinner!!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.