We have stayed at many places on Mackinac Island and found Bogan Lane to be average for the price you pay. It is less since you have to share a bath room. We did not like this idea at first but it actually worked out quite well. The beds are another story......they look like they are from 1950 and very thin. The wood floor in our bedroom was covered with dust bunnies.
The first morning at breakfast I had a hair sticking out of my cinnamon muffin. The second morning my butter knife at my place setting looked like it had already been run through the butter. I did not want to be rude and say anything to embarrass the owner (sitting with us for breakfast) sice we were sharing the table with other inn guests. I just opted not to use my knife that morning! All the while the owner's dog is wandering around the table - not very hygienic if you ask me.
During our entire stay we were reminded that check-out time was at 10:30AM. We were told this about six times the day we were departing. It felt as if the owner was done being hospitable and the sooner we leave the better. I cannot say I felt very welcome at this B&B and will not be returning.