We had lunch one day and dinner the next. An average prime rib on the dinner visit kept the score from being higher. We experienced friendly, attentive service on both visits. Our lunch meal was excellent and a good value. The Margherita flatbread (with some italian sausage added) was crisp on the outside and chewy on the inside with a burst of italian flavors in every bite- all herbs were fresh. One order could have served two and made it an even better value. The cheeseburger surprised my wife with how juicy it was and it too came with very fresh toppings. Dinner was fine - and the view from our table on Main Street was excellent. The prime rib came with some kind of gravy rather than a side of au jus and horseradish. I should have sent it back since it was the priciest item on the menu. I will still return on my next visit for the flatbread!
If you own or manage Goodfellows, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.