During our three days on the island we ate a five different restaurants. Since this was our first visit we decided to rate the restaurants from one to five, one being our favorite and five our least favorite. Interestingly we agreed on the rating, which is unusual at best. The first two were easy picks, but the last three were more challenging; so we decided they all tied for fifth place. There was nothing wrong with any of the three, but in our opinion they just didn't measure up to the first two. Unlike the first two, there was nothing about the experience that made us want to return. We do plan to return to the island for another visit however.
If you own or manage Horn's Gaslight Bar & Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.