We went into a little restaurant just as it was closing. The woman - a long time resident of the island- directed us to the Mustang Lounge - "where all the locals go for pizza". The Mustang is not on Main Street and is somewhat removed from the tourist surge. What a wonderful treat. It was the best pizza we had ever eaten. The crust was thick and the toppings bountiful - and the cheese- it tasted fresh and delicious. We took it back to our hotel and tried to finish the whole thing and mourned when we just couldn't eat another bite. You won't go wrong here!
If you own or manage Mustang Lounge, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.