We have been a part time resident on Cape Cod for 5 years and we just found the Optimist Cafe this year. The food is more upscale and a bit pricey, but fairly consistent with other restaurants on Cape Cod. The menu offers a nice variety, even a quiche with potato crust (weird but tasty). The restaurant is right on 6A in Yarmouthport and worth a visit. If it's not too busy, they may let you take a look around the restaurant. Its' an old home registered with the historical society and has some wonderful character. There are many tourist trap restaurants in Cape Cod, this is NOT one of them.
If you own or manage Optimist Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.