We are here at the Cape for one week and we were looking for something special to celebrate our anniversary. We read many great reviews on Trip Advisor, so we booked a reservation. Here is what made this a great experience.
Easy to find, plenty of parking, super friendly staff, our waiter was attentive but not overbearing, menu had lots of selection, food was great, portions were big, wine selection was also very good.
This was arguably one of the best meals we've had on the cape. What we also enjoyed was that the menu had many seasonable choices. I'd recommend the watermelon salad, grilled lamb chops, duck with strawberry rhubarb, and for dessert - the strawberry rhubarb shortcake was really good.
I've read on other reviews that sitting in the Tavern is the way to go. I agree. We were looking to do something a bit casual, so the tavern was perfect. There is a bit more activity in the tavern, but it's not too loud. The dining room would have been too quite for us.
I also read that some people complained about price of the meal. My thinking on this is that the price is offset by the generous portions that you get. I thought this was a very good deal overall. No complaints on price from me.
Can't wait to come back for another visit.
If you own or manage Old Yarmouth Inn, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.