I went here two nights in a row in September close to off season to the upstairs part of the restaurant. The service really wasn't great we just went in for drinks the first night and had to move because it was a little chilly we were told by the server to stay as long as we wanted since we weren't in his section.
The second night we went we were trying to enjoy a nice relaxing dinner and the waitress kept pressuring us to place the rest of our order. We wanted to wait until we were done with our appetizer to order our meals and she asked repeatedly if we were ready to order. Then to make matters worse she kept coming by asking if I was done with my meal and I had only taken a couple of bites. Just really horrible service.
Then next we sat there and watched as a couple asked for a table that had just become available and they gave them the run around for minutes instead of just cleaning the table so that they could sit down. Then when they were finally seated the manager came over and argued with the customer instead of saying sorry. Probably my worst dining experience on the Vineyard.
Upsides there is a great view from the upstairs dining are and the food is ok.
If you own or manage Nancy's Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.