Buyer beware! Do Not stay here!! Rooms are over-priced and underwhelming. The grounds are anything but a resort. The innkeeper is rude and never available. But that's probably because she's busy spying on her guests. Upon checkout she admitted to have been behind our room and looked into the window at night. She even monitored the amount of people that came in and out of the room. Very creepy!!! "Continental" breakfast was a pitcher of oj and stale muffins in windowless mildew basement. Save yourself the hassle and be able to actually enjoy your vacation!

the photos on their website are much nicer than the actual rooms. we had a nice time there but all in all there are a few issues. the rooms, especially the bathrooms are a bit dated. the grounds could be a bitter kept as well. and the breakfast facilities including breakfast are really a bummer. however i guess it is still a good value for the yard...

We have just returned from almost a week in this resort and had a wonderful time. The setting was exactly as advertised and seemed to be a good value for the price. Claudette is a gracious and efficient hostess - she was always available for any need and helpful when asked, but never intrusive or hovering. Breakfast on the front porch each morning was a great start to our days. Our room was clean, comfortable, and charming. We are not sure what some earlier reviewers expected, but we felt that the web site very accurately depicted the resort and its amenities. The entire house was clean, bright, and peaceful. The bus stops right in front, for those who wanted to travel the island that way. The walk to Oak Bluffs center requires caution if you use the main street (NY Ave), but is very doable. We would highly recommend this resort to anyone looking for a quiet, welcoming, friendly place to stay on MV!

MightyAlbion,

I could not agree with you more. In fact you found adjectives that better/best describe what we felt during our visit, e.g. windowless basement, over-priced and just stale and antiquated; really an overall let down especially if you have had nicer and become accustomed to better experiences. So, much for expectations. Thanks for your review - it confirmed our experience!