We tried this place after receiving a gift card and were not disappointed. As people have already said, we noticed right away that most people there are regulars, all friendly with the wait staff and each other. We happened to go on a Tuesday, and they have a great special on both Monday and Tuesday nights, $26 3-course dinner for two. I loved my meal and my boyfriend liked his. I was too full for dessert but he said his was great.
Also the building is under construction so the seating was limited, but we still had no wait. However until the construction is done, it may seem crowded on a busier night because the seating area is temporarily smaller.
If you own or manage A J Tomaiolo Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.