I was hoping for an experience similar to Parker's Maple Barn in Mason, NH, which is a family favorite, but the Sugar Shack was not quite there. Menu was somewhat limited for breakfast, but you can definitely get your standard french toast, pancakes, eggs, and bacon. The syrup is outstanding, and you can purchase some from the store there. I did not have their freshly made donuts, but they looked good. I think what was probably most disappointing was the ambience in the "restaurant". Basically, it was tables and chairs set up in a large open room in a barn-style building with very bright (harsh) lighting. (By comparison, Parker's feels more like a lodge, with lots of rustic wood and pellet stoves.) I would not make a special trip to go here but was in the area and wanted to try it. Service was good, and when I went (late Feb) there was no wait.
If you own or manage North Hadley Sugar Shack, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.