There's Mexican food and then there's gourmet Mexican food. This is the latter. Try to arrive early, it fills up in the Summertime. Try to sit on the porch, the sunset is really nice.
Overall, the food is fresh and properly made. The tequila list is over the top. Go and have a series of small dishes for the table, it's a diverse method to walk one through the offerings.
The service is the best; very knowledgeable, very helpful and always moving.
Parking is tight, but you can probably get away with parking in one of the neighboring stores' lots.
If you own or manage Xicohtencatl, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.