Charming, historic hotel in a perfect location. Joanne and staff are helpful, and knowledgable about the area. The hotel has bicycles that you can borrow to explore the area.
We stayed in a harbor-view room, which had a window view of the harbor. Room was cozy and comfortable. Just outside the room was a balcony where guests could get a better view of the harbor.
Given the lack of sleep quality, I don't think this would be our first choice for lodgings during future visits to Martha's Vineyard.
When guests close their doors -- the doors seem to close very loudly as there is no mechanism to prevent same. This is bothersome when awoken by a loud 'symphony' of doors being closed by other guests.
The hallways are somewhat narrow, combined with the thin walls, conversations in the hallway seep into the room.