I wish I could have an option for 3.5 stars, because this isn't quite a 4 and not quite a 3. Alchemy is a place I have visited once or twice over the years, finding it overly complicated and inconsistently prepared, and the service very inconsistent. We tried it in October thinking maybe it would be different, and it sort of was. Easy to get a table, reasonably quick service (if a little unprofessional and indifferent), and some yummy food, though the sea scallops over lamb ragout was maybe a wee bit more complicated and not quite as cohesive as we may have wanted. If it were always October on the Island, I;d go again. Otherwise, it's a decent place but not in my top.
If you own or manage Alchemy, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.