In case there is anyone out there who is still debating a stay at the Captain's House Inn, I would say "Just do it!" You won't regret the decision -- except it may forever ruin your experience at any other B&B. We were back for what is becoming a tradition -- celebrating a birthday in Chatham and at the Captain's House. We stayed in the Intrepid on our first visit and loved it; this time our two nights were in Wild Pigeon. You climb the narrow winding steps and discover a hidden gem at the top -- Wild Pigeon! The room is huge with two separate seating areas -- one by the fireplace, the other facing the TV. Really, you could entertain in this room!
Breakfast both days was both beautifully presented and delicious. The staff is friendly and so competent that you hardly notice them busy at work. Jill makes the rounds to greet her guests and make sure they are comfortable and happy. I would definitely nominate Jill and Jim as Innkeepers of the Year!