We stumbled on this little gem while spending a weekend on the Cape. First we had a great breakfast there. The next visit we had a very tasty lunch with fabulous Key Lime pie for desert. Now, we make special trips (we are an hour and a half away) with a large cooler that we bought just to transport the second to none pies back home! We love the Chicken Pot Pie and Shepards Pie the most and take home several of each to have in our freezer. The homemade crust is always a taste treat and the pies are loaded with meat. So easy to pop on the oven after a long day at work and in just over an hour, you have an incredibly tasty home cooked dinner. Combine that with the desert pie, and you have a great dinner. Our favorite desert pie is the Toll House Cookie Pie, no diet is worth skipping that one for!
If you own or manage Centerville Pie Co., register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.