This is some of the best seafood I have eaten for a very fair price. It's very casual. Your food comes in a styrofoam platter and you sit on benches/picnic tables with sand at your feet. You're at the beach...it's only right.
The crab cakes are nothing but crab meat; no filler. The shrimp is delicious and the sides are also delicious. We ordered red skin potato salad and steamed corn on the cob. Now, if you're into crabs, you must go to On the Bay. All you can eat crabs for $25. They bring what seems to be an endless supply of crabs. They stop when you tell them to stop.
Like many of the other reviewers, I will reiterate the importance of arriving early. Tables fill up pretty fast. We had to share a table with another family, but it was big enough that we really didn't notice. Also, parking is extremely limited. If you're hotel or lodging accommodations are in close proximity to On the Bay, I definitely recommend walking.
If you own or manage On the Bay Seafood, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.