Fratelli's is consistently top notch - my favorite place to eat if they are open. Atmosphere can be a bit noisy, and they are always busy when they are open (Watch out on Sundays - they are only open seasonally on Sundays).
The servers are the best in town, and among the best you will find anywhere. Management obviously pays close attention to seeing that they make every visit special - from the hostess to the servers and even the bus boys. The food is excellent - they don't get too fancy, but they always do it well. Crabcakes are huge and loaded with big lumps of crab meat - not shreds, and almost no filler. Their Italian selection will have something for everyone, and the same for their seafood which is also fresh and tasty. The Calamari is better than most I have had anywhere - tender with a good portion, but beware their sauce for calamari is spicy for some - ask for marinara if you have an aversion to peppers. The bread, pizza, and stromboli are all excellent. (Try the buffalo chicken pizza or stromboli - they have so many great italian dishes, it's easy to pass over this delicious gem). We are usually too full to sample the desserts (The bread is so good, it's easy to fill up on it before dinner), so I can't comment on them. Highly recommended.
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.