Not sure why this place is listed under attractions rather than restaurants (albeit take-out), but I promise you this is the best way to get a great meal that you can eat on their back deck or on the fabulous beach just a couple of blocks away.
Everyone seems to be focused on their lobster rolls, but I'm going to suggest an alternate route. Go for the lobster salad, people! How can you beat $5.95 for 8 oz of sweet and succulent meat?? You don't have to wait for them to make it because it's ready to go in the refrigerated case and you can call ahead to make sure they have it or to ask them to hold one for you.
And while the lobster salad shines on its own, I can vouch from years of first-hand experience that it is most perfectly paired with their homemade cole slaw, which is available at a steal. It's perfectly crunchy, slightly sweet, not overdressed and begs to be enjoyed in alternating bites with the lobster salad. You've got to try it and once you have, you'll never go back to anything else!
This review is the subjective opinion of a TripAdvisor member and not of TripAdvisor LLC.