If you're going to call yourself the "Bagel Caboose," you are going to have to make sure your bagels are good and fresh. They were neither during our recent visit.
We each ordered a breakfast sandwich on a toasted bagel and decided to share a muffin while waiting for them to be prepared. Our first clue was that all the "fresh baked goods" were displayed in saran wrap. Nevertheless, we asked that a muffin be heated, preferably grilled. The guy behind the counter said he couldn't grill a muffin but could microwave it. Second clue: how was he going to prepare breakfast sandwiches if he couldn't use the grill? Answer: Microwave them.
The bagels were toasted lightly but the tops were steamy, the egg was either powdered or precooked somewhere other than on the premises. Ditto the bacon in my sandwich and the sausage in my husband's. The entire thing was microwaved and then served. If we had been blindfolded, we couldn't have guessed what we were biting into, the sandwiches were so tasteless. We took a couple of bites and pushed the whole thing away - muffin too since it wasn't fresh and was soggy.
This little place could be very charming if they offered a decent product but they don't seem to even try. We like to support local efforts but this place isn't worth it.
If you own or manage Bagel Caboose, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.