I only stayed here one night while visiting friends, but the reviews are accurate. This is an old-style motel that is meticulously maintained by the owners. Some physical features of the room were somewhat improvised, from the plastic folding bathroom door to various little signs and instructions (including one not to use the old thermostat and directing you to where the new thermostat is), but nothing is shabby or left in bad repair.
And the room was very clean!
Another nice touch was the provided continental breakfast. The owner apologized for it being less fancy/extensive since it turned to "low season", but it was fine.
The road in front of the motel (US 1), is a bit noisy, but the motel sits back far enough so it really didn't bother me at all. Slept like a log.
For the price, you can't do better.