I came in with my boyfriend and another couple to Peter Otts and sat at a table in the corner of the restaurant facing the water. The view was amazing! I ordered the Calamari salad and it was delicious, there was little dressing so that it didn't over power the flavors of the calamari. The other couple with us enjoyed crab cakes which they said were loaded with crab and were very flavorful. I enjoyed the Halibut for dinner which had an amazing sauce on it that really made the flavors of the fish stand out. My boyfriend ordered the sirloin and said it was the most tender and flavorful steak he's had ever! (And we eat steak at restaurants a lot!) The desserts were too good to pass up even though we were both stuffed so we split a peanut butter pie which was awesome, there wasn't a crumb left on the plate! We truly enjoyed our experience here and will definitely be back to their new location regardless of those upset about the missing salad bar. If you want food from an all you can eat buffet you are in the wrong town anyway!
If you own or manage Peter Ott's on the water, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.