We liked the central location of the inn, perfectly in the middle of Main Street, and from the top floor (room 408) we had great views of the harbor and looking down onto the street.
The inn has beautiful brick detail, I don't know what they converted it from input whatever it was they kept original details intact. Our room had a cool brick wall and was definitely cozy. The bathroom was just ok and had a couple of issues: very tight shower, and lots of mildew in the shower. The room also is limited on outlets. The bed is really comfy and the room gets great light in the morning.
Fitness room was good, again very small but good cardio equipment. Breakfast was nice, all the basics you could want. Service was very friendly, and I liked the cookie jar in the lobby (perfect after dinner snack).