It cost 54.00 for 4 to eat at the buffet and have soft drinks. The food selection was limited and of poor quality. I had previously eaten at the Black Buggy near Evansville and was expecting the same kind of tasty homemade food, but it was not to be. The buffet selections were not fresh and did not seem to be homemade. The taste was very bland. I had meatloaf that didn't seem to be made of ground beef and a few of the items, including a soup, seemed to be thrown together from leftovers. I definitely was disappointed and would not recommend this restaurant.
If you own or manage Black Buggy Amish Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.