As a dedicated, devoted and lifelong lover of NY style pizza, I gave in to my Midwestern husband's craving for a "Chicago deep dish pizza" and we stopped here. OMG! We ordered the double crust deluxe and I forgot all about my missing real pizza. The family atmosphere, fast service and absolutely delicious pizza has made this our favorite pizza parlor in Indiana. Every ingredient was flavorful, the cheese was exceptional and although it was a double crust - it wasn't the thick doughy crust that always has gagged me.
We ordered a large and brought 3/4 of it home. Reheated in the oven, it was remarkably good - that's if we didn't almost eat two slices cold (good too!!) while waiting.
Ohhh, I really, really love pizza....and this Oley's is the only one who has my heart.
P.S. - Although there is another pizza place with the same name in Fort Wayne, it is NOT a part of this restaurant nor does it have the same food as this place. Just the name is coincidental.
And call ahead...it's always busy!! (The pizza we ordered will take 45 minutes to make - so be aware of that!!!)
If you own or manage Oley's Pizza, the Original, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.