I have been a loyal customer of Horseshoe (formerly Caesars) Indiana for years and here's why: by far this place has the most generous comps of all the Indiana casinos. We are not high rollers. My parents aren't either and they get the most comps there of all the Indiana casinos. So, even though this is the farthest from my house of the Indiana casinos (at 2.5 hours) I will keep coming back. The hosts have all been very responsive, friendly and accommodating.
Slots are slots wherever you go. These are no looser or tighter than any others in Indiana. Slots are RANDOM and have essentially the same percentage payout wherever you go in Indiana (granted Vegas percentage payouts are better but I'm talking strictly Indiana).
The walk to the casino from hotel is far - if you walk. I always wait for the little golf cart. It's fun. It does stop running at 3:00 am on weekends though.
I see a lot of complaints about thin walls on here. I have never noticed that - have perfect hearing - and have stayed on just about ever floor of the hotel over the years.
Best of all about this hotel - the indoor pool/hot-tub area are very nice and never crowded. My husband and I and our 4 year old go for the night and my son just loves it. He swims for a couple hours with us then we all go to dinner. Sometimes we all go for a walk outside on the walking trail behind the hotel. Definitely the best place to bring a child of all the Indiana hotel casinos.
Staff at hotel, from valet to room service are the friendliest. All in all - it is my favorite of all the Indiana casinos.