If you are from Jersey, NYC, or Philly and find yourself in Carmel Indiana stop by as it will make you feel like home. All others should come for the great sandwiches, which put the local Indiana Deli Shapiro's to shame. I will concede that I can't fathom why it takes so long to make the sandwiches. While they warn you about the wait, I must say,hire some more staff. If you don't want to become totally frustrated, come at off hours or order for pick up with plenty of advanced time built in. Hence the low rating for service. The servers are pleasant enough and have always been great to the kids. Sign the wall if you are from back east, it is great to see all the hometowns represented.
If you own or manage Jersey's Cafe, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.