I only found out about this place during my last semester at IU. I wish I had known about them sooner. Excellent homemade ice creams. Many flavors are thick and almost fudgy. A lot of interesting and creative flavors. I think they serve the best ice cream in Bloomington even though they're not as famous as Chocolate Moose, Coldstone, or Bruster's.
If you own or manage Hartzell's Ice Cream, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.