The prior review is old. As I understand things, the new owners have completely updated the menu. My coworker and I were the lunch guests of a supplier. I totally enjoyed my Reuben sandwich. The beef was tender and perfectly done. The kraut was tangy without being bitter. The cheese was excellent. I would have preferred dark rye, but the marble rye was very good, perfectly toasted. And the sandwich was huge. Our hosts and my coworker enjoyed their meals as well. The service was quite good, and the prices were reasonable. I found the decor subdued, but pleasant. The place was spotlessly clean. If I'm ever in Rockford again, I'll eat there; no question.
If you own or manage New Mill Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.