They have a huge range of items, from bagels to bialys to omelettes to soups to burgers to salads. It's a classic Jewish deli, which I craved every day I was going to college in Virginia. I love their low-fat tuna salad, but more than anything I could eat any one of their kugels every single day. They'll heat it up if you ask, which you should!
Their omelettes are great, too, and come with a free bagel which you can have wrapped up if you don't want to it eat it right then.
It does serve kind of an older crowd, but it's the very definition of a Highland Park institution and I love coming here!
If you own or manage Once Upon a Bagel, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.