The burgers were definitely affordable but not very tasty. The patties are really thin and greasy and the buns we got were stale. If you're going in to hear "Cheezborger" tossed around, this is the right place. The staff is fun to watch at the grill but I would only go back for a beer at the bar (where there are some local characters hanging out) and not for the Cheezborgers. If you decide to try a Cheezborger anyway, at least order a double, otherwise you will leave hungry.
If you own or manage The Billy Goat Tavern, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.