Stopped in for the first (and probably the last) time last night, and was disappointed to find the place was poorly managed. The bar had 2 people sitting at it, and all the rest of the places were littered with past customer's drinks/napkins, etc. who had obviously left and the bartender didn't clean up after them. After wiping a spot for us to sit down at, it took the bartender 10 minutes to even notice us, she was no where in sight. Upon being seated, I noticed many (at least 7) tables where customers had eaten and left, had not been bussed, and all their dirty plates/glasses, etc. were left there for everyone to see. Additionally, the carpeting was messy, not swept and tidy. Booths were crammed in making you part of your neighboring booth's conversations whether you wanted to listen or not. The waitress, Lisa, was very personable and helpful, however, the food was mediocre at best. The best thing here is the aquarium!
If you own or manage Islamorada Fish Company, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.