My family and I have been here 3 times in the last two years. Overall they always offer generous portions and the selections are very fresh. Among the favorites for us are crab cakes (my favorite), grilled shrimp, harvest cobb salad, waldorf salad side, carrot and raisin salad side, pumpkin muffin.
I can see the reviews are somewhat polarized, either people love it or they hate it. I will say that it is a somewhat rustic setting (an old grocery store converted into a restaurant), and that everything is together in one room, so it is a bit noisy with the clatter of things. This can be annoying or in our case contributes to overall atmosphere.
Our family of five gets out of there for ~$50, excluding tip. (kids are 13,11,9).
Our favorite place on St. Simons for eating out.
