A group of 5 went to Seajay's for early supper and ordered a variety of dishes. My usual favorite is crab cakes and my tendency is to check them out when going to a new restaurant. Please don't order them at Seajay's! They seem to be mostly filler and cooked way beyond done. Almost had to cut with a knife. Those lucky enough to order fried shrimp were pleased and since they shared a couple, I would agree. My guess is that if what you want is fried seafood, it may be okay. Service was pleasant and accurate, although it took longer than anyone expected for such an early time. I'd say half full at best. Every thing on Jekyll is expensive so even though this is a casual sit down restaurant, I would not consider $$ in cost. It is more like $$$.
If you own or manage Seajay's Waterfront Cafe & Pub, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.