I really wanted to rate this as a "5" instead of a "4". What a great group of employees! All were alert, courteous, responsive and helpful. The facilities are super -- even on a rather cool couple of days in December, the pool was plenty warm to swim in, the outside spa was hot, and the fire pit was a nice place to socialize. Breakfast was good enough, and we loved the ability to enjoy a hot tea or coffee at any time of day or night. We enjoyed the available bikes for a very reasonable rental charge, as there are great bike trails on the island.
While the rooms were very well appointed, and attractive-- the noise insulation was well below average. We were awakened several times by footsteps over our head, and conversation from the room next door. It did not seem that these other guests were inconsiderate or abnormally noisy, either-- just the the floors and walls were not very soundproof, especially for a newer hotel. Otherwise, we enjoyed this hotel thoroughly.