We come to Treasure Island every year on Spring Break and I make it my mission to try the key lime pie at every restaurant we visit. Our restaurant today didn't have KL pie on the menu--boo!--but recommended this shop. I got my KL pie to go and my husband got a waffle cone of pecan ice cream. A little pricey, but good. As other posters have noted, old-fashioned candy is also for sale. A fun place to go for dessert.
If you own or manage Sweets & Treats, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.