We went as a group with younger kids, young adults, and parents, and had a great time. Good variety of rides, and lines weren't too bad even though it was a Saturday in the summer. Having booked a cabana was a wise choice - it gave us a place to hang out between adventures (pricey, though), a place to lock up purses and phones, and a chance to get out of the sun. Like others, I would recommend water shoes. And lots of sunscreen. A couple of rides gave some of our parties small injuries - rashes, cut hands. There appears to be a few maintenance needs, but overall things appeared fairly safe. The Lazy River was a big favorite, with or without the tubes. I would go back.
If you own or manage Adventure Island, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.