Went here on a Monday Eve; was surprised downtown Sarasota was so-so quiet. It's January, snowbirds s/b in migration!
We had a party of six .... Salad to start, with chicken parm, eggplant parm, pastas & five boys burger. All good; comfort food not high level cuisine. Ingredients seem good quality. Sauce was light and layered well in the parm. Buger good both beef and pulled pork ( beaware you'll never bit into this burger as it's 6" in highh with bun). All come out at same time. Can't speak to service as we were lost in conversation. Reasonably priced. Wine, both glass and bottle, was ok; had not aftertaste. No deserts. Sitting inside and out; you can see in easily so you'll know immediately if tables are filled. Walked but saw parking but if downtown is busy, beware then!
If you own or manage Caragiulo's, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.