We arrived at 11:30 in hopes of avoiding the long line out the door we read about. There were about 6 people waiting in line. We got in relatively quickly. We had the sweetest waitress named Jean who was quick and efficient and knew her stuff! My husband got the pan fried chicken, stuffing, and mashed potatoes. While he loved the chicken, he thought the potatoes and stuffing were just okay. I got 4 sides: the mashed potatoes were great I thought, the macaroni and cheese was nothing special...no crunchy topping..just tasted like macaroni with melted American cheese, the cole slaw was okay and tasted like out of a deli, and the potato pancakes served with sour cream were excellent. The fresh peach pie was amazing...huge cut up pieces of fresh peaches with a fantastic crust. The key lime pie tasted like all the others I've had in Florida. We sat in an awkward spot by the bathroom, a round table. It seemed like everyone had to stop at our table before getting into the bathroom. Not the best place I've ever eaten but very good and I would definitely stop in again, especially for the pies!
If you own or manage Yoder's Restaurant, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.