We had an awesome waiter, great personality, and ability to read his customers and offer suggestions.
Wife was going to order a Philly cheese steak, but he suggested a 'chicago'. She said it was awesome. They apparently slow cook roast beef in au jus all day. The Cole slaw that comes with it is pretty good too - not soaking nor over powering.
Pizza was ok. Had a few in Sarasota now and seems to be on par with others. Flat, tough dough, hard to cut with knife or teeth. Other than that, good.
Good seating for a bar and plenty of it. Pool table, darts, typical bar games.
If you own or manage Evie's Tavern, register now for free tools to enhance your listing, attract new reviews, and respond to reviewers.