Our family of 2 adults and 2 8 year-olds ate at the Island Cow on the recommendation of other families with children. The menu is huge and has something that would appeal to the pickiest eater. Unfortunately, our meals were very disappointing. My son was happy with his chicken fingers and french fries, but my daughter said that her mac and cheese (which looked remarkably similar to the one from the box) didn't taste like it had cheese in it. My husband's sandwich had no flavor and my salad was just OK. As bland as the meal was, the service was good and the bill came to about $45, excluding tip. Also, we chose to eat outside and the bugs ate us alive. Skip the Island Cow and spend the same amount on a much tastier meal at Cheeburger Cheeburger.

Ate supper here on Oct. 9th. Extremely noisy, so that we could not even have dinner conversation. Lots of families with kids, plus the reggae music, made for a very loud atmosphere. The food was OK, but the service was not good. The waitress came by once after serving our food, but never checked again for water refills until two of us had completely finished our dinners (even though she passed us to wait on other tables). Would not recommend unless you like a zoo-like atmosphere for your meals.

We enjoyed a late lunch at the Island Cow on 10/5/08. Their menu is enormous. My husband had a grouper sandwich that he said was excellent. I chose the fried artichoke and goat cheese poor boy and it was delicious. The staff was very friendly and service was good.

Unfortunately for me, I didn't discover this place until my last night on the island. I loved the food (especially the Shepherd's Pie) and the desserts are huge!